Shingle brands: good, better, best
Honest, research-based comparison of the major asphalt shingle manufacturers in the U.S. market. We source from manufacturer technical data sheets, warranty documents, and ICC-ES evaluation reports. We do not independently test shingles — every claim on these pages cites the manufacturer or a third-party certifier so you can verify it yourself.
How the tiers work
Every major residential asphalt shingle manufacturer offers three rough tiers of product. Good is the entry 3-tab or basic architectural — lowest cost per square, shortest warranty, thinnest mat, and typically the go-to for rental property or secondary structure re-roofs. Better is the core architectural line — the shingle that will appear on most residential quotes. Best splits into two separate premium paths: a thicker dimensional shingle (longer algae warranty, heavier mat) or a luxury/designer shingle that imitates wood shake or slate. Some brands also offer a separate UL 2218 Class 4 impact- resistant shingle eligible for insurance discounts in hail states.
The tier name on marketing pages does not always match real-world performance. A “premium” designer shingle is priced for the look; it does not necessarily carry a stronger wind rating or a longer warranty than the core architectural line. Where this happens we flag it explicitly on the brand page so you can separate the aesthetic upgrade from the performance upgrade.
Brands we’ve researched
We are building this library one brand at a time, starting with the largest U.S. asphalt shingle manufacturers by market share. Each brand page covers the Good / Better / Best product line, warranty fine print, distinguishing features, who the brand fits, and honest concerns.
- CertainTeed6 tiers covered
- GAF4 tiers covered
- IKO7 tiers covered
- Malarkey5 tiers covered
- Owens Corning6 tiers covered
- TAMKO4 tiers covered
Future additions planned: Owens Corning, CertainTeed, Malarkey, IKO, and TAMKO. Brand inclusion here does not imply endorsement.
Research, not product reviews
These brand pages are an editorial summary of publicly available manufacturer documentation, warranty language, and third-party certification records. They are not product reviews — we have not installed, weathered, or stress-tested any of these shingles on a real roof. For actual installation decisions, pair this research with a local licensed contractor who has hands-on experience with the specific product in your metro and your climate.
We do not accept payment from any shingle manufacturer to include, exclude, or rank their products. See our editorial standards for the full disclosure.
Ready to get quotes on a new roof?
Two minutes of questions. A local roofer reaches out through our lead partner. See how we handle your quote request for how routing works and what to verify yourself.
Start with my zip code